CMHC's own study finds home equity tax 95 per cent unpopular
Despite spending nearly half a million dollars studying and promoting a home equity tax, the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation's own study found 95 per cent of social media comments are against a home equity tax, according to records obtained by the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
“A home equity tax is so unpopular that the only people who support this tax are the people who are paid to study it,” said Franco Terrazzano, Federal Director of the CTF. “Canadians can't afford higher home taxes and politicians say they don't want a home equity tax. So why is the CMHC wasting time and money studying home taxes?”
When Canadians sell the house they own and live in – their primary residence – they are not taxed on the money they made on the sale.
In 2020, a group called Generation Squeeze received $250,000 from the CMHC to write a report on housing policy. The report published on Jan. 5, 2022, calls for a home equity tax targeting the “housing wealth windfalls gained by many home owners while they sleep and watch TV.” The CMHC also gave Generation Squeeze an additional $200,000 in 2022 to influence public opinion in favour of a home equity tax.
The CMHC conducted an in-house study of the social media response to the home equity tax proposal from Jan. 5, 2022, to Jan. 10, 2022, according to the records obtained by the CTF. Of the 3,093 comments collected, 95 per cent were negative.
The commenters believed the tax would be unfair to Canadians who worked hard to invest in their homes and hurt Canadians who rely on their home equity for retirement.
Comments also raised concerns about the consequences of a home equity tax.
“People doubt that the tax would help to curb real estate prices and some worry that it would drive prices even higher,” reads the CMHC’s overview of the comments.
“It turns out a random sample of social media commenters have a better understanding of economics than Generation Squeeze,” said Terrazzano. “New taxes won’t make homes more affordable; tax hikes make things more expensive. We need to improve affordability by building more homes and you build homes with hammers and nails, not tax hikes.”
An email chain from March 2022 shows the CMHC’s Wendy Pollard raising the idea of cutting off additional funding to Generation Squeeze. Pollard asserted that giving more money to Generation Squeeze to promote a home equity tax is “not worthwhile.”
The CTF asked the CMHC whether it followed Pollard’s recommendation to stop funding the promotion of a home equity tax.
“Further work in this area was not necessary,” the CMHC told the CTF.
While the CMHC confirmed that no more money would be provided to Generation Squeeze to promote its home equity tax report, the CMHC would not rule out future funding for home equity tax research or future funding for Generation Squeeze.
“If Prime Minister Justin Trudeau wants Canadians to believe his government isn’t scheming up a home equity tax, then he needs to make it absolutely clear that the CMHC will not spend any more tax dollars funding home equity tax propaganda or Generation Squeeze,” said Terrazzano.