The federal government is already on track to blow its budget by $20 billion. That’s astonishing when we’re only about halfway through the budget year. But here’s the most amazing part: Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland called her fiscal update “prudent.”
Freeland said the government would spend $452.3 billion in April’s budget. Now Freeland says the government will spend $472.5 billion. In seven months, Freeland is somehow managing to spend $20 billion over budget.
Freeland’s April budget wasn’t exactly the epitome of austerity.
Freeland’s April budget contained $90 billion in extra spending compared to pre-pandemic. And the government was already spending all-time highs before the pandemic. Freeland is outspending her own big-spending budget that she penned seven months ago.
Freeland is pinky promising taxpayers a balanced budget by the end of 2027. Taxpayers should be skeptical.
First, that’s after the next election.
Second, the Parliamentary Budget Officer’s numbers aren’t nearly as rosy.
The government’s balanced-budget projections depend on an extra $129 billion in revenue compared to the beginning of this fiscal year. The PBO released its budget projections on Oct. 13. The PBO projects revenues in 2027 will be $11.1 billion lower. The government wouldn’t balance the budget using the PBO’s revenue projections. It would have a $6.6-billion deficit in 2027.
What if a recession is right around the corner as some economists predict? Freeland hasn’t shown any ability to reduce spending to match lower revenues. Freeland can’t even keep spending in line with her own budget.
Third, higher interest rates could tear a bigger whole in Freeland’s budget.
Desjardins projects interest charges will cost taxpayers $49.8 billion next year. That’s $6.5 billion, or 15 per cent, higher than the costs Freeland is using. The PBO also projects higher future interest charges.
Bottom line: the deficit in 2027 would be $9.4 billion using the PBO’s revenue and interest numbers. This is a larger deficit than the fiscal update’s downside scenario, which projected an $8.3-billion deficit in 2027.
It actually gets worse.
The Trudeau government hasn’t met a budget target it couldn’t blow. It’s been more than eight years since Justin Trudeau claimed the “budget will balance itself” as a member of Parliament. The Trudeau government hasn’t stumbled into a balanced budget. It will have added $561 billion to the national debt by the end of this year.
Ottawa’s culture of frivolous spending and never-ending deficits needs to end.
Freeland claims fiscal restraint. But the government spent $1.3 million on a week-long trip for the governor general and $6,000 per night for a single hotel room during the Queen’s funeral. The government isn’t getting the big spending right either. It gave 312,825 bureaucrats a raise while their neighbours lost pay during lockdowns. The government is going way over budget with its military procurement. Now, it’s on the hook for $300 billion for navy warships. And the finance minister is spending $20 billion over budget.
More government borrowing means more tax dollars lost to the bond fund managers. Interest charges will cost taxpayers $252.5 billion through 2027. That’s a cost of $6,300 for every Canadian.
The more money the government spends on luxurious trips, the less money we have to hire more nurses. The more pay raises the government gives itself, the less money parents have to put their kids in hockey. The higher the debt, the higher the interest charges and the more likely taxes will rise.
Canadians haven’t seen one iota of spending restraint from this government. The first step for Freeland to deliver restraint is to stop spending $20 billion over her own budget.